AI Skill Report Card
Empirical Stock Market Testing
Quick Start
Pythonimport pandas as pd import numpy as np from sklearn.ensemble import RandomForestRegressor from sklearn.metrics import mean_squared_error, r2_score import statsmodels.api as sm # Load and prepare data data = pd.read_csv('stock_data.csv') features = ['volume', 'sentiment_score', 'platform_mentions', 'technical_indicators'] X = data[features] y = data['next_period_return'] # Split data maintaining temporal order split_point = int(len(data) * 0.8) X_train, X_test = X[:split_point], X[split_point:] y_train, y_test = y[:split_point], y[split_point:] # Test hypothesis with ML model model = RandomForestRegressor(n_estimators=100, random_state=42) model.fit(X_train, y_train) predictions = model.predict(X_test) print(f"R²: {r2_score(y_test, predictions):.4f}") print(f"Feature Importance: {dict(zip(features, model.feature_importances_))}")
Workflow
Progress:
- Hypothesis Formation: Define testable research question
- Data Collection: Gather stock prices, user data, platform metrics
- Feature Engineering: Create predictive variables and technical indicators
- Exploratory Analysis: Examine distributions, correlations, stationarity
- Model Selection: Choose appropriate AI/ML/DL approach
- Backtesting: Test on out-of-sample data maintaining temporal order
- Statistical Validation: Perform significance tests, robustness checks
- Economic Significance: Assess practical importance beyond statistical significance
- Documentation: Record methodology, assumptions, limitations
Key Steps Detail
Data Preparation:
- Handle survivorship bias using point-in-time datasets
- Address look-ahead bias in feature construction
- Winsorize outliers at 1st/99th percentiles
- Check for data snooping across multiple tests
Model Validation:
- Use walk-forward analysis for time series
- Apply Bonferroni correction for multiple testing
- Implement cross-validation respecting temporal structure
- Calculate Sharpe ratios and maximum drawdown
Examples
Example 1: Social Sentiment Impact Input: Twitter sentiment scores, Reddit mentions, stock returns Output:
Hypothesis: Social sentiment predicts next-day returns
Model: LSTM with sentiment features
Results: Significant coefficient (p<0.01), 0.12% daily alpha
Economic significance: 31.2% annual Sharpe ratio improvement
Example 2: Platform Trading Volume
Input: Robinhood user holdings, trading volume, price movements
Output:
Finding: 10% increase in retail platform holdings → 2.3% price increase
Methodology: Panel regression with fixed effects
Robustness: Significant across 95% of bootstrap samples
Publication: "Retail Trading and Stock Prices" - Journal of Finance
Example 3: Deep Learning Price Prediction Input: High-frequency price data, order book, news sentiment Output:
Architecture: CNN-LSTM hybrid model
Features: 50 technical indicators + NLP sentiment scores
Performance: 67% directional accuracy, 1.8 Sharpe ratio
Validation: 3-year walk-forward backtest, transaction costs included
Best Practices
Research Design:
- Pre-register hypotheses to avoid data mining
- Use established asset pricing factors as benchmarks
- Report both in-sample and out-of-sample results
- Include transaction costs in performance metrics
Data Quality:
- Verify data integrity with cross-references
- Handle corporate actions (splits, dividends) properly
- Use CRSP/Compustat standards for academic rigor
- Document all data preprocessing steps
Statistical Rigor:
- Apply Newey-West standard errors for autocorrelation
- Use Fama-MacBeth procedure for cross-sectional tests
- Report bootstrap confidence intervals
- Conduct robustness tests across subperiods
Model Implementation:
- Implement proper cross-validation for financial time series
- Use ensemble methods to reduce overfitting
- Apply regularization (L1/L2) for feature selection
- Monitor model stability across market regimes
Common Pitfalls
Temporal Data Leakage:
- Using future information in feature construction
- Incorrect train/test splits that break temporal order
- Forward-filling missing data inappropriately
Statistical Issues:
- Multiple testing without correction
- Ignoring heteroscedasticity in residuals
- Assuming normal distributions without testing
- Cherry-picking significant results
Economic Realism:
- Ignoring transaction costs and market impact
- Testing on unrealistic position sizes
- Overlooking short-selling constraints
- Missing market microstructure effects
Data Problems:
- Survivorship bias in stock selection
- Point-in-time data availability issues
- Inconsistent data frequencies across sources
- Missing adjustment for stock splits/dividends
Overfitting Indicators:
- Dramatic performance difference between in-sample and out-of-sample
- Models with hundreds of parameters and few observations
- Perfect or near-perfect in-sample fits
- Strategies that work only in specific time periods